BCCI's statement in full
- With a view to strengthening domestic cricket, efforts will be made to ensure that all Test / ODI Cricketers play Irani, Duleep, Challenger and some Ranji Trophy Matches.
The Indian domestic season runs roughly from mid-October through mid-March. A cursory glance at India's schedule over the next two years shows that India has International commitments ( both home and away) that overlaps with this.
The series that are lined up are not trivial either. Pakistan and Australia this winter, England, South Africa and New Zealand next winter.
And if Lalit Modi has his way, there will be a ton of inconsequential ODIs thrown into the mix to meet contractual obligations.
So, effectively, we are left with the winter of 2009 before this particular clause can even come into play.
2. Every Association will be directed to prepare fast and lively wickets for domestic tournaments.
Another eyewash.
That the BCCI is compelled to make this statement despite ground realities shows how distanced they are from their own operations.
In an earlier post, I had highlighted the result/draw numbers of some of the more "prominent" venues in India.
Nagpur had famously produced a green top in 2004 against the Australians, Mohali did the same against Bengal. And both venues resorted to producing tripe wickets since.
Directing associations to produce "fast and lively wickets is one thing, ensuring that the "fast and lively" wickets are not tampered with quite another.
- The BCCI will do away with home and away rotation and allot venues for Irani Trophy, Duleep Trophy, Deodhar Trophy, Ranji Trophy semi-finals and finals and one-day all-India knockout.
This is one point that I have no issues with - take away the built in biases that home curators have for their team and make the playing field more even.
- It was decided that all affiliated units should start their own state academies by April 2009. These academies would be linked to the National Cricket Academy for the purpose of uniformity in coaching.
The National Cricket Academy is in operation 3-4 months a year. Are the state academies going to follow the same model?
And when the Board talks of uniformity of coaching, has it taken any steps to regulate coaching in India? Every day we see new Cricket coaching "academies" spring up, some by ex cricketers, some others by fly by night operators. There is no base standard across these coaching "academies" nor are most of the coaches certified ( either by the Local Association or the BCCI). Parents have no idea what their kids are getting into, there is no cap on how many kids can be coached by the "coaches" in one session.
Why aren't the Board or local associations focused on this aspect of coaching? Along with having State Academies in place by 2009, why not also regulate coaching by this time frame?
By doing so, state selectors for all age groups will at least have an idea of the base minimum skills the individual players they are selecting have and the standard of coaching will be baselined.
- It was decided to scrap the present zonal representation in the senior and junior selection committees. BCCI will appoint selectors on a full time basis based upon the eligibility criteria which would include stature as a player, selection experience etc. They will be remunerated suitably and appointed for a two-year term. The BCCI will take steps to propose necessary amendments to the Constitution to give effect to the above decision.
This has been hailed as the big step forward by all and sundry. I think this is an eyewash. The reason I think this is an eyewash is because this comes into effect within a year’s time.
If the Board truly desired to do away with Zonal representation, they could have set themselves a more ambitious deadline - before the selection of the team for Bangladesh.
Amending the Constitution is a technicality, and Pawar rules the roost so getting the amendment is a non issue.
There is in place a selection committee that is "honorary" in nature and who will sit to decide India's team to Bangladesh.
How difficult is it for the Board to decide terms of remuneration for these 5 worthies as a start and then, over the period of one year, do away with the Zonal nature of the Committee?
If the intent is there, this could have been implemented within the month - we will have to wait for a year by which time this proposal would have been forgotten.
- Regular and frequent Under-19 and India A tours to Australia / England / New Zealand / South Africa / West Indies will be undertaken.
Nice - but will Lalit Modi and his team really exert themselves in working out these schedules with the required diligence? Please do remember that there are no revenues to be generated from these tours.
Also, will the A team selection be done in tandem with the Team Manager, coaches and Selection Committee of the senior team?
- The Working Committee has directed the Selection Committee to send a young team to Bangladesh under an experienced captain. The selection committee, after discussions has appointed Rahul Dravid as captain for India's tour to Bangladesh, Ireland and England.
The need to blood youngsters was there even if we had won the World Cup. And Bangladesh provides us just the opportunity as it is a relatively low profile tour while not being an easy one.
That said, we will need the senior players for the more high profile tours to England and Australia and against Pakistan.
So, youth first - yes, but a little more nuanced.
- BCCI will appoint a permanent manager for the Indian team for a two-year term. The Board will also appoint a permanent Media Manager for a two- year term.
No names were mentioned. No names have been mentioned. Don’t expect any names to be mentioned either.
- Notice will be issued to Sachin Tendulkar and Yuvraj Singh under Rule 38 of the Memorandum and the Rules and Regulations of the Board asking for an explanation for their comments made to the media.
Look Mama, I can a voice.. Let me make some noise. Ho hum!
10. Working Committee approved the Performance-based Payment to the players and decided to do away with the present gradation for Retainership. Apart from the payment, the following points would form a part of the contract.
· A player will endorse not more than 3 sponsors / products
· No Sponsor can contract more than 2 players.
· The players will not be allowed to do any sponsor-related events 15 days before the tour and also during the tour.
· Before every tour, all the contracted players have to undergo a fitness test and only those who fulfill the benchmarks will be considered for selection.
· No player shall have exclusive contracts with electronic or print media. Only the captain can write a column or talk to the media but not exclusively.
· The players shall take prior approval of the Board before signing any endorsement contract and will submit a copy of the agreement to the Board. All the players shall submit a copy of the existing contracts with sponsors to the Board.
· All the players will have to play a stipulated number of domestic matches when not playing for India.
· In the event of injury to the player, the Board will compensate him the match fees that he would have earned for a maximum period of six months.
The Big News Item!!!
The Board took an extreme position with regards to player contracts – a position that was both populist and untenable. A day later, the climb down has begun.
Partly because of the legal issues, partly because the BCCI knows which side of its bread is buttered, the Board is taking a more centrist position now.
The BCCI knows that without the players, it has nothing to show for as an organization. The BCCI also knows that it needs to crack the whip to keep the players in line every once in a while. Hence the thunder and the fury first up, and then the sops .
Expect a little more of the give and take and lots of happy family statements over the next few days.
11. The Working Committee decided to form a Cricket Advisory committee consisting of the following ex - captains: Kapil Dev, Sunil Gavaskar, MAK Pataudi, Chandu Borde, Ravi Shastri, Krish Srikkanth and S Venkataraghavan under the Chairmanship of President [Sharad Pawar] and will include all the Office Bearers.
Jobs for the Boys!!!
- The working committee appointed Ravi Shastri as Cricket Manager for the India's tour to Bangladesh. It was further decided that Venkatesh Prasad will be the bowling coach and Robin Singh, the fielding coach for the tour.
Right- a bowling coach and a fielding coach and a manager for one tour, and then what? But then again, why am I surprised?
Since Shastri has made all the right noises on leading the squad as Manager, why was it not possible to offer him something more long term – allowing him to mould the team the way he chooses to.
And if the captain can be appointed for a medium term, why are the bowling and fielding coaches, integral cogs of the team, appointed on a per series basis?--Maybe the BCCI has done more than what people expected, maybe they met people’s expectation but I remain skeptical. The BCCI has a history of making promises and conveniently forgetting them. Wont hold my breath waiting for the current “proposals” to materialize!!