to take on the England Lions starting Friday the 13th.
Wasim Jaffer
Gautam Gambhir
Sachin Tendulkar(c)
Saurav Ganguly
Yuvraj Singh
MS Dhoni(wk)
Zaheer Khan
Ranadeb Bose
Ishant Sharma
RP Singh
Ramesh Powar
Here's why
- Jaffer needs a good workout before the first test and his showing against Sussex was not upto scratch.
- If Karthik is to play the first test as a keeper, then it will not be prudent for him to open. In that case, Gambhir becomes the automatic choice for opener.If Karthik plays as opener,then Dhoni should don the gloves.
- Sachin and Saurav need a hit in the middle and so become automatic selections.
- Yuvraj Singh, like Wasim Jaffer, did not have a decent outing against Sussex and so, makes the cut.
- Dravid needs rest and recuperation for his strained calf. And Laxman had a pretty decent outing against Sussex, so both he and Dravid can sit this game out.
- MS Dhoni like Yuvraj, needs some time in the middle. If the finger injury has sufficiently healed, it will behoove India to have him as first choice wicketkeeper.
- Zaheer Khan picks himself
- Ranadeb Bose as opposed to Sreesanth will be contentious, especially given the proximity of the three day game to the first test. But as the three day game is more an assessment of the resources and their match fitness, it would make sense to play both Ishant Sharma and Ranadeb Bose. Also, going into the first Test, if India choose to front up a four seam one spin attack, the identity of the fourth seamer is better established now than during the game.
- RP Singh hit his straps in the game against Sussex and it is a line call playing him versus Sreesanth. While RP Singh participated in the ODI jamboree in the detour that was Ireland, Sreesanth was recovering from the flu. However, Sreesanth was impressive against Sussex and seems to have gained decent match fitness.
- Ramesh Powar because he needs a game. Anil Kumble was, as is his wont, accurate. And looked in good nick with the ball in hand.Does he need another game before the first test? I don't think so. I would rather have the bench get some match time and assess how they are shaping along rather than over play the guys who are automatic selections for the first test.
An intriguing battle beckons..
10 comments:
Homer
Don't want to be picky-choosey but why not go with as close to the playing XI for the first test as possible? Whats the point of asking for mor e warm up games if we then use them to rest/cool off?
e.g - Sreesanth's had just one game this tour yet....
Cheers
Sfx,
Thats a line of thought I pursued for a while.
Here is the thing - we are playing 3 tests and 7 ODIs. The bowlers are pretty much the same in both forms of the game. Sreesanth showed form in his one outing so far. Do we want him bowling over 3 days and then again over 5 days?
Would we rather not see Ishant Sharma and ranadeb Bose get an outing to seal the third/fourth bowlers spot?
Cheers
Homer,
Fortunately, or otherwise - think RP Singh's second innings batting heroics sealed that spot. And he didnt do badly with the ball either (compared to those in contention.)
I think we'll get some idea of what we can expect for the first test on the basis of the team - and partic the 1st innings in the game starting tomorrow. In that I think we'll be quite close to teh playing XI barring injury /illness.
Conjecture...
I agree Sfx although I do not see any point in either Rahul playing through his injury or VVS blocking say Saurav or Yuvi in the warm up game..
Anyways, all will be revealed on friday :)
Is Dhoni injured? Didn't read about his fingure injury anywhere?
Can you give the link, Homer?
Also, apart from Dravid, who needs to recover from his calf strain, I think India should play its first XI.
I think India more or less know their starting line up for the first Test. This could be that team bar a couple of players.
Agree that the England Lions team looks good so will make for an interesting contest.
Hoping to go and watch on one of the days.
Chandan,
Karthik donned the gloves in the match against Sussex ( second innigs as Dhoni was nursing a bruised finger).
I dont disagree with the thought of playing the first XI, I also think we should use this opportunity to play fringe players to ascertain the composition of the starting XI.
Cheers
Rashmika,
Looking forward to the game day report and pictures on your blog.. :)
Cheers
What is the name of your blog, Rashmika?
Homer
Hope the weather holds up, I can't wait to see the boys in action.
Chandan
My blog is called Cricket Chat and is at
http://rash-cricketchat.blogspot.com/
Post a Comment